Reservoir Inn

4.3 ( 203 reviews )
Checking... 05:00 AM - 09:00 PM See Hours
$20–30
157 Basin Rd, West Hurley, NY 12491, United States

If you're searching for a delightful culinary escape in Ulster County, Reservoir Inn is a must-visit destination. This continental restaurant, nestled in West Hurley, NY, has garnered rave reviews for its impeccable dishes and charming ambiance. Diners like Melanie Delano rave about the beef stroganoff, a dish that leaves a lasting impression and seems to set the standard for all others. Additionally, her experience with the duck has raised the bar sky-high, showcasing the restaurant's commitment to exceptional quality.

Returning customer Janine Mower highlights its reputation as a hidden gem, especially for celebratory dinners, while the daily specials, like Spatzle and Jambalaya, have received enthusiastic praise. For couples seeking a romantic evening, Jamie Dreyer lauds the perfect steak and beautiful stonework, enhancing the overall dining experience.

From the first appetizer to the last sip of a meticulously crafted martini, Cindy Bell praises the complete meal experience, making it clear that Reservoir Inn is dedicated to flavorful dishes and friendly service. With such commendations, it’s no wonder this establishment has developed a loyal following. Reservations are highly recommended—at Reservoir Inn, you’re in for a memorable treat!

Amenities and More

  • Service options
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Highlights
    • Fast service
    • Great beer selection
    • Great cocktails
    • Great coffee
    • Great wine list
  • Popular for
    • Dinner
    • Solo dining
  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Offerings
    • Alcohol
    • Beer
    • Cocktails
    • Coffee
    • Comfort food
    • Small plates
    • Spirits
    • Vegetarian options
    • Wine
  • Dining options
    • Dinner
    • Catering
    • Dessert
    • Seating
    • Table service
  • Amenities
    • Toilet
  • Atmosphere
    • Casual
    • Cosy
  • Crowd
    • Groups
    • LGBTQ+ friendly
    • Tourists
  • Planning
    • Accepts reservations
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
  • Children
    • Good for kids
    • Kids' menu
  • Parking
    • Free parking lot
    • Parking

Reviews For Reservoir Inn

Melanie Delano
Jun 30,2025
Dinner was amazing as usual. My husband loves the stroganoff, one of his favorites. We changed it up and got the satay shrimp for an appetizer. I got the duck. I'm afraid Tim has ruined me getting duck anywhere else. His is so good none others compare. Wow! Can't wait to go back.
Janine Mower
Jun 20,2025
A hidden gem in the Ulster County dining experience. Seven of us had Christmas Eve dinner here- our 3rd year in a row. Two of us ordered from the daily specials menu and both dishes, one a Spatzle and one a Jambalaya got good reviews. Two of us had the Chicken Piccata and we are still talking about how good it was. Reservations suggested. Give them a try. You won't be disappointed
Jamie Dreyer
Jun 11,2025
The steak is perfect! My wife and I came here for date night and had a great time. The stone work and old timber’s are beautiful, the service was spot on, great wine selection, and the food is sooo delicious! And when the check came I was surprised by how reasonable the price was. We’ll be back!
Rani
May 16,2025
The beef stroganoff is exceptional. I couldn't stop raving about it for days. I will be getting takeout for other family members (outside of the area), so they can enjoy it too! Looking forward to my next visit
Cindy Bell
May 11,2025
Delicious meal from appetizers to desserts - friendly service and a very nice martini. Came back for the meatloaf- extra tasty!
Dave Johnson
May 9,2025
The building is historic and nicely appointed. The food was fresh, hot and excellent. Staff was friendly and courteous.
Peter T Glass
Apr 9,2025
If you are looking for glitz, lots of shiny chrome and food that is served in just a few minutes on a big plate with little portions and pretty looking sprinkles and designs, then go to NYC - this place is not for you! At the Reservoir Inn you get 1) Tim (owner/Chef), 2) Karen (bartender, waitress, busboy, cashier and host - she may do the dishes, too), 3) old inn atmosphere, 4) good food with a take home container as the portions are huge, and 5) great prices unlike in nearby Woodstock. Everything is cooked to order and is worth the wait. Yesterday, we had a party there attended by 40 friends. The buffet was ready upon arrival, bar was open and service was as expected. Welcome to the Reservoir Inn, a fond memory of what going out to dinner was like in those slower, more relaxed times.
C H
Mar 13,2025
Best kept secret near the resevoir. DELICIOUS meal. Priced right.

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

Restaurant Catedral
(432 review)
Restaurant Catedral
  • 43000, HueJutla - Tamazunchale 23, Centro, Huejutla de Reyes, Hgo., Mexico
restaurant
+52 789 896 0252
Lupita's Mexican Restaurant and Bar
(277 review)
Lupita's Mexican Restaurant and Bar
  • 668 E Prater Way, Sparks, NV 89431, United States
Mexican restaurant
+1 775-355-1770
Fish River Grill
(2501 review)
Fish River Grill
  • 1545 Gulf Shores Pkwy, Gulf Shores, AL 36542, United States
seafood restaurant
+1 251-948-1110
Jack's American Bistro
(207 review)
Jack's American Bistro
  • 730 Glen St, Queensbury, NY 12804, United States
American restaurant
+1 518-798-1797
Ruta Ukrainian Restaurant
(395 review)
Ruta Ukrainian Restaurant
  • 327 7th St SE, Washington, DC 20003, United States
Ukrainian restaurant
+1 202-492-7986
Fika Bournemouth
(266 review)
Fika Bournemouth
  • 7 Westover Rd, Bournemouth BH1 2BA, United Kingdom
Coffee shop
Aiyara Thai Cuisine
(315 review)
Aiyara Thai Cuisine
  • 1590 Walkley Rd, Ottawa, ON K1V 6P4, Canada
Thai restaurant
+1 613-526-1703
Ben Lora Cafe & Bookshop
(496 review)
Ben Lora Cafe & Bookshop
  • 2, 2 A828, Oban PA37 1QW, United Kingdom
cafe
Johns of Instow
(336 review)
Johns of Instow
  • 4 & 5 Marine Parade, Instow, Bideford EX39 4HY, United Kingdom
cafe
+44 1271 860310
Pho House Cafe & Deli
(661 review)
Pho House Cafe & Deli
  • 316 SE 123rd Ave Unit A3, Vancouver, WA 98683, United States
Vietnamese restaurant
+1 360-892-3400